This quick & easy No Bake Coconut Cream Pie is so light, fluffy, and creamy! It’s also a mile-high! You can prep this easy Coconut Cream Pie in minutes, avoiding long, hot days in the kitchen.
To easily view all the blog recipes, follow along on Pinterest!
Hey hey! It’s been a little while. Maybe the longest break I’ve ever taken, and unplanned, as usual.
I have a lot to share, so let’s jump right in. This is a No Bake Coconut Cream Pie… except for the crust. I used a store-bought pastry crust that needed baked, and I baked it (instructions included in recipe card below!). BUT, to make this easy Coconut Cream Pie a ‘no bake’ through and through, then just pick up a prepared pie shell. Simple as that.
This No Bake Coconut Cream Pie is a pudding pie technically. It just does not taste like a pudding pie though. I love pudding pies, don’t get me wrong, but this tastes much fancier and more luxurious than an easy pudding pie.
It only requires a few ingredients, and takes about 5 minutes to prep. Its impact is sooo much more than a basic, easy, prepped-in-minutes pudding pie.
The texture of this easy Coconut Cream Pie is so light, fluffy, and creamy, and a bit mousse-y. I used coconut cream pudding mix, not vanilla pudding mix, and that helps to amplify the coconut in this pie.
It’s also a mile-high. I love a really tall pie, and this delivers.
When my S.O. tried it, he said: “Wow, this is hands-down the best Coconut Cream Pie I’ve ever had.” I have no idea how many Coconut Cream Pies he’s tried in his lifetime though. Still, if it stood out as the BEST one he’s ever had, then it’s got to be good. I adored it myself.
I’ve made a Chocolate Coconut Cream Pudding Pie in the past, but the chocolate made that pretty different, and he’s tried this Millionaire Pie (Piña Colada Pie), which has a lot of coconut in it, so that’s a few, at least. His mother makes a pretty mean Coconut Cream Pie, but yeah, I don’t know that he’s an absolute expert.
Nevertheless, this Coconut Cream Pie is a gem of a recipe. Especially for summer. You won’t spend a lot of time in a hot kitchen!
I might have more no bake pies than anything else on the blog. I mean, seriously easy pie recipes. Other than easy Bundt Cake recipes, I probably have the most easy pie recipes!
Some of the most popular ones are this No Bake Peanut Butter Pie recipe, of course, but also these: No Bake Chocolate Creme de Menthe Pie, Chocolate Irish Cream Pie, No Bake Nutella Cheesecake, and Cookie Butter Cheesecake. I’ll stop, but I could go on and on…. 🙂
No Bake Easy Coconut Cream Pie
This quick & easy No Bake Coconut Cream Pie is so light, fluffy, and creamy! It's also a mile-high! You can prep it in minutes, avoiding long, hot days in the kitchen.
Ingredients
- 1 9-inch prepared refrigerated pie crust or your favorite pie crust recipe
- 14 oz. can sweetened condensed milk
- 1 cup cold milk
- 2 - 3.4 oz. boxes instant coconut cream or vanilla pudding mix MUST be instant pudding!
- 1 1/2 cups shredded sweetened coconut
- 8 oz. container Cool Whip or whipped topping thawed
- 1 cup toasted coconut optional garnish
Instructions
- Arrange pie crust in a 9-inch deep dish pie plate, and crimp or scallop the edges.
- Line the pie crust with foil or parchment paper, and fill with pie weights or dried beans.
- Bake at 425 degrees for 10-12 minutes, or until edges are browned.
- Remove from heat, carefully remove parchment and pie weights, and cool completely.
- Meanwhile, prepare filling.
- In a large bowl, whisk together sweetened condensed milk, milk, pudding mix, and coconut.
- Fold in whipped topping.
- Pour into prepared pie crust. The pie crust will be VERY full, but it will all fit if you just keep building it up in the center. Careful not to let the filling seep over the edges of the crust. 🙂
- Refrigerate til set, at least 2 hours.
- If desired, garnish with additional whipped cream and toasted coconut. Cut and serve.
Laura Trama says
Mine did not get thick like the picture. It was too much like pudding to put in a pie shell. How did you get yours so thick like the picture?
Sarah says
Did you double check all the ingredient amounts? I’ve made this pie a few different flavors, and this is how it turns out! You didn’t make the pudding first, correct? You just mix the dry pudding with the other ingredients….
Sabrina says
So do you just mix the dry pudding to the other ingredients?
Sarah says
Yes, it’s specifically listed in the directions, but you don’t make the pudding and then add it, you add the “pudding mix” with other ingredients as written in the instructions! Good luck!!
ALICE says
I love this idea. I made mine and cupcake pans. Made my crust and Then followed your instructions it was awesome they were beautiful I can’t wait to get your email for other great ideas
Sarah says
You made mini pies in cupcake pans? I love that idea! Those would be so fun for holiday parties! What kind of crust did you use? Thank you so much for sharing your version! I’m glad you liked this recipe. 🙂
Pam Whelan says
Have you ever added coconut extract to the thawed wjipped topping?
Sarah says
I have! But I didn’t in this pie — I have done it in the past though with really good result. Great idea!! I should’ve done it here too!!
Tracye Ford says
I used coconut extract in the pudding mixes and it was great. Strong coconut taste. The pie was a huge hit at Thanksgiving and I will make it again.
Sarah says
Great tip! Thank you so much for sharing that!! I’m so glad it was a hit, and I hope you had a great holiday!
Patti says
This is such a good cream pie and very versatile. The first time I made it as a coconut pie, following the recipe. My husband ate the last piece for breakfast! The second time I made it, a week later, I made a chocolate cream pie by replacing the flavor of pudding. After the pie shell came out of the oven to cool, I put a layer of chocolate chips on the bottom to melt as it cooled. I added mini chocolate chips to the pie mixture. I don’t care for cool whip so I make my own whipped cream using heavy cream, making extra to layer on the pie before serving. My family really loves this pie recipe. Next time I’m going to make banana cream, lining the bottom with sliced bananas.
Sarah says
Hi Patti: Thanks so much for sharing your feedback – I’m so glad you like this pie. And thanks for the fabulous tip! Your chocolate cream pie sounds INCREDIBLE. I love the banana cream pie idea too. I agree that homemade whipped cream is so much better than Cool Whip, but I do sometimes like a short-cut. 😉 Thanks again for sharing your feedback!
Bailey says
Has anyone tried this with a graham cracker crust? I’m trying to avoid making a crust last minute!
Sarah says
You can substitute that – no problem. Or if you find a store-bought shortbread crust, that’d be great too! It will pile HIGH though — you could possibly make two pies if you’re using a small store-bought crust!
Sherry Turnbull says
I used a no bake short bread crust . It was great ! This was the best coconut cream pie I ever ate . It was a great hit for Christmas!
Thanks for sharing the recipe. Looking forward to trying it with a few other replacements to make different flavor pies .
Lynn says
Thanks for answering the gram cracker crust question. I have
To eat GF for medical reasons. So I can get a GF
Gram cracker crust
Sarah says
Yes, that totally works! Any crust you like or that fits your dietary needs will work. Thanks again. 🙂
Tricia says
How much coconut extract would you put in if you’re using vanilla pudding to make it more coconutty?
Sarah says
1 teaspoon, I’d say! A teaspoon is usually pretty potent!
Valerie says
I LOVE this recipe! It was my first time making this and it was sooooo easy and turned out amazing!! For the pie crust I got a 10″ graham cracker crust to give it some extra space/not be so full. I just baked it in the oven for 5 minutes and let it cool before I put the filling there. I used 2 coconut cream jellos instead of vanilla but I did add a splash “maybe 1 teaspoon” of vanilla extract to my mix. I would definitely recommend toasting some coconut for the top because it really does finish the pie and bring everything together. It was a little sweet for me because I don’t eat sweets too often so I may see if they have a sugar free version of the coconut cream jello for next time and do one regular and 1 sugar free. Chances are though I may just keep it the same and splurge 🤗 haha. Take care and enjoy everyone!! I have a picture but unsure how to upload it on here. Sorry!
Sarah says
YAY — I’m so happy to hear this!! Aaaah, I’m so glad you loved it. It’s a really popular recipe, and I do think it’s a hit for most people. It’s just really easy and really delicious. I never underestimate a pudding pie, they’re underrated, ya know? Thank you for sharing your tips and swaps – that’s so helpful to others. I hope you had a fabulous holiday, and Happy New Year!!! 🙂
Rhonda says
Has anyone used coconut milk for this recipe?
Just wondering if it would change the pies test and/or texture?
Sarah says
In place of the 1 cup cold milk? I think you could do that! I think that would really turn out well.
Betty says
Can you use cook pudding for this recipe
Sarah says
Hi Betty: I’m not sure, but I don’t think so! I’ve never worked much with cook pudding mixes. In this pie, you don’t even make the pudding, you use the mix along with other ingredients, so I’m just not sure cook pudding would work. I’m sorry!
Lynne says
I’m going to make this today. I could only get vanilla pudding though🙁 and I don’t think I have any coconut extract, is it going to taste at all like a coconut cream pie? LOL
Sarah says
Lol! If you put lots of coconut in it? Heck yes. And for good measure, throw some toasted coconut on top! I think it’ll still be delish. 🙂
Cathy says
I purchased refrigerated pie crust and froze it for future use. I’ve made this pie once leaving it in the tin pie pan. I want to use the other pie crust in my nice pie pan. Would you just try and pop it out of the tin pan when frozen and place in a pie pan to thaw and bake? Thanks it’s so amazing!
Amanda says
I accidentally used ‘cooked’ pudding powder by mistake instead of the instant pudding powder. Will this cause my pie to not set properly?
Sarah says
I honestly cannot say for sure because I rarely ever use ‘cooked’ – I’m just not familiar with it at all. I hope it still turns out for you!! I’m sorry!!
Tawney says
Hi Amanda,
Just curious, How did your pie turn out using “cooked” pudding instead of instant??
Shai says
Can I use half and half to substitute the milk?
Sarah says
Yes, you could definitely do that!
Jill Hall says
This is absolutely delicious and super easy to make! I used a deep dish frozen crust and that left room for more whip cream on top. It’s now a Family favorite.
Sarah says
YAY! So happy you liked it. Lots of readers have made it, and are also really loving it. That makes me so glad to hear! Thanks for sharing your feedback!! So helpful to know.
Jen says
Do you have to add coconut to it if you use coconut pudding? Cause it has coconut in it already is why I ask?
Sarah says
The coconut pudding has coconut flavor, and not a ton of coconut, though there is some. I would personally still add shredded coconut, but if you think you’ll prefer it without, you could probably get away with that. I personally recommend it, but the structure of the pie will still hold up if you don’t include it. Make sense? Thanks!
Barbara McCollum says
Can’t wait to try this pie. Do you happen to have a easy No Bake Sour Cream Raisin Pie Recipe?
Sarah says
I don’t! I’ve never heard of that. Sorry I couldn’t be more help!
Pauline says
Question for you all. I’m going to use the instant coconut cream instead of the vanilla, do I still need to add more coconut? Or cut the amount of the coconut flakes? Thank you
Sarah says
That’s probably a personal preference! If you just want coconut flavor, the coconut pudding is sufficient. But the coconut pudding contains a pretty minute quantity of actual coconut. If you want to have shredded coconut in your pie, add it. 🙂 I hope that helps.
Ruth says
Hi – I’m looking forward to making this for a Thanksgiving and cannot find Jello coconut cream anywhere. If I use the vanilla instead, how do I increase the coconut flavor?
Thank you.
Sarah says
Hi Ruth: You can’t find Coconut Cream pudding mix? It looks available at Walmart and Walmart Neighborhood Markets, perhaps give them a call ahead if you haven’t already checked there? I’m sorry you can’t locate it! The best way to amp up the coconut flavor would be to add coconut extract! At least 1 1/2 tsp., but you could taste & see from there, adding more if needed.
It will still have good coconut flavor from the shredded coconut as well!
Laura says
Hi, I made this recipe a couple weeks ago! Hands down the best no bake recipe I have made! Coconut cream pie is my favorite, so I have made quit a few. Thank you for sharing! Also, glad I’m not the only one that ca no longer find the coconut cream pudding mix. Wal-Mart, Publix nor Winn Dixie have them in stock and have said not sure when they will be available. I may be forced to use cook type? Any suggestions?
Sarah says
Darn, I am so bummed to hear that about the coconut cream pudding! I haven’t had an issue locating it, but that’s definitely worrisome to hear. I love that stuff!! I think what I’d do instead of using cook & serve is just use vanilla or French vanilla instant pudding, and add coconut extract. I really feel that will get a similar effect. Have you been able to locate coconut extract?
Summer says
Do I put the whipped topping in to the pudding mixture or put it on top? I am making this for my grandpa for tomorrow. We lost my grandma in August and he loves coconut and I want it to be really good for him. I am just making sure I do it right.
Summer says
Never mind I answered my own question.
Sarah says
Hi Summer: I’m glad you found the answer! I hope the instructions were easy to follow, and I certainly hope you all enjoy the pie. I’m sorry to hear about the loss of your Grandma. I can’t imagine how hard the holidays will be this year. You’re sweet to make something special for your Grandpa. My Grandpa always loved coconut too actually. I hope your family has a wonderful holiday!
Sabrina says
Made this for Thanksgiving as I wanted to offer pies besides the normal pumpkin pie (made pumpkin pie too of course). The coconut cream pie was popular among many guests, and most of it was gone before the night ended.
Simple yes flavorful dessert that is a must for holidays and bbqs
Sarah says
I’m so glad you enjoyed it! I hope you had a great holiday. 🙂
Elishia Phillips says
Would it hurt the actual pie to top it with meringue?
Sarah says
Np, I don’t think so! If you’re not planning to put it in the oven, it should be fine. If you are going to char or singe the top of the meringue, it would have to be done with a small kitchen torch vs. a broiler in the oven, know what I mean? But it shouldn’t compromise the pie, no!
Robin says
Can I use non dairy whipped topping instead of dairy?
Sarah says
For the garnish, yes! I’m not sure it would work for the filling. I haven’t worked with that type of ingredient much, I’m sorry to say! I believe it would be fine, though I think that type of product deflates a bit more easily. The pie might be less fluffy, but it should be alright!
Genny Darrett says
OMG!!!!!! Delicious turned out just like you’re picture. Added coconut extract because could not find coconut pudding.Gave my neighbor some and she went crazy over it .Thank you !
Sarah says
YAY!!! I’m so happy to hear that! Awesome. Thank you for sharing your feedback. 🙂
Hannah says
I’m going to try using coconut milk to replace the milk! Can’t wait to try it!
Sarah says
That should work just fine! Let me know how it turns out with that swap! 🙂
Laura says
This is amazing!! I’m obsessed with coconut, Im making this again this weekend.This was a big hit with my family too!
Armelle F says
Looks delish. I want to try it but will never use cool slwhip type of ingredients. Any way you might have tried it without the cool whip? Thanks for letting me know.
Sarah says
You could make it with homemade whipped cream! Have you ever made homemade whipped cream? At least that removes a lot of potential chemicals and preservatives.
Logan says
Will this recipe work without folding in the whipped topping into the filling, and just using it as a topping instead?
Sarah says
It won’t work wonderfully, no. It’ll be like a very thick, overly sweet pudding. I think I wouldn’t do it, unfortunately! Are you looking for a different type of dessert?? What are you hoping to have it turn out like?
Sharon says
Made this today and my hubby and I both agree that it is time to retire my cooked recipe.It is Deeelish!I had a prebaked crust that I made a few weeks ago in the freezer already so it couldn’t have been any easier.I too couldn’t find coconut pudding so I used vanilla,but I used sweetened condensed coconut milk.I also reduced the milk to 1/2 cup and substituted cream of coconut for the other half.That, with the coconut gave it plenty of coconut flavor.I also put some toasted coconut on top. Easiest pie I ever made and soooo good.
April Martin says
Yep, it’s all that. It’s light and very sweet, just the way I like it. It’s not a heavy custard coconut nor was it supposed to be so it was just right. I have a KILLER picture if you want it. I just don’t know how to post it in here.
Sarah says
Yes!!! You took a picture? I’m working on a site redesign, and I would LOVE to be able to share readers pictures on it. Would you email it to ksgrossett@gmail if you think of it? Thank you so so much for your kind comment and your feedback. I’m so happy you liked it. 🙂
Giftbasketworldwide says
Totally enjoyable one!! Thanks a lot!
Cindy says
My boyfriend is very picky when it comes to desserts.
I made this recipe with a homemade pie crust. He absolutely loved it!
Rhonda says
I read somewhere that the coconut cream pudding is only available from October to December
Sarah says
Oh, really? It’s seasonal? I’ve never heard that. I have not had trouble finding it in most grocery stores, but maybe supply has also changed!
Kathy Prince says
I looking de the instant coconut cream but nobody sales it here
Sarah says
Hmmm, that’s too bad. I usually find it easily. You can use vanilla or French vanilla, and add 1-2 tsp. coconut extract!
Sherry says
No Bake Coconut Cream Pie is to die for! So delicious and easy! My roommate, a chef, raves about it. He asked if I’d make one for his dad for Christmas. Yes, I will!! Thank you for this amazing (truly) recipe. It’s now a Thanksgiving and Christmas tradition for me.
Sarah says
That makes me so happy to hear!! I’m so thrilled you guys love it. Thank you for letting me know, it literally warms my heart. 🙂 You’re not alone — so many people love this pie too. It’ a popular one. Happy Happy Holidays!!
Sue says
Hi. Do you know if i could freeze your lovely no-bake pies?
Sarah says
I do think this would freeze well, but I have not actually done it, to tell you the truth! I would get it refrigerated til really firm, freeze without a lid for a few hours, then wrap it once it’s firmed up so the structure of it isn’t compromised. To thaw, just remove it to the fridge to thaw right in the fridge. I hope that helps!
Susan says
What if I don’t have pie weights or beans what can I use as a substitute in the pie crust when I bake it
Sarah says
I sometimes will use coins or change! Lay down parchment on the crust, and throw some quarters on top!
Christine says
I don’t understand the purpose weighing down the pie crust. Can you explain?
I asked my husband to buy regular coconut milk for a completely different recipe (like for a Thai dish!) and he bought coconut sweetened condensed milk. :/. So I landed here after searching what I could make with coconut sweetened condensed. After reading all the comments about not being able to find the coconut pudding, I think this would be a good alternative to amp up the coconut flavor. FYI, he got it at Walmart.
Question: your recipe calls for 14 oz sweetened condensed but the can my husband bought of the coconut version is only 11.6 oz. Should I reduce the milk maybe so it stays thicker to compensate for the fewer ounces? I’d like others to weigh in who have used coconut sweetened condensed.
Also, for the gluten free peeps like myself, maybe try a home made almond or walnut pie crust crust. You basically grind up the nuts and mix in melted butter and sugar then bake. You could even use gluten free pretzels or gf graham crackers. A quick search will turn up recipes.
Can’t wait to try this! Thanks!
Sarah says
Hey there! A regular pastry crust will puff up quite a lot of it doesn’t have pie weights to keep it from doing so. It’ll become a big tent. You can absolutely make a different crust though — anything will work really. A nut crust is a wonderful idea. The gluten-free pretzel crust sounds fabulous too! Any crust of your preference will work. 🙂
I don’t know that anyone else has made this with coconut sweetened condensed milk, but it does sound amazing! Let me know how it turns out!
Katie says
Hi! I made this for Easter and there’s so much I loved about it, but it was just a little too sweet for me. Do you think it’s because of the sweetened condensed milk or the coconut cream pudding? Just wondering how to keep the beautiful texture, but made it a little less sweet. Thanks!
Sarah says
Thank you so much for your comment, and for sharing your feedback! I think it’s possible that the sweetness would be cut enough by using unsweetened shredded coconut. That change alone might sufficiently reduce how sweet it is! Otherwise, it’s hard to substitute the pudding or sweetened condensed milk without sacrificing texture. My next best idea would be to use homemade whipped topping rather than Cool Whip. Cool Whip is pretty sweet. Homemade whipped cream without sugar would probably help cut down on sweetness too. Look up recipes for homemade whipped cream, which is just whipped heavy whipping cream, but don’t use any sugar in it. I think that could be an option….
Pam Mc says
I’m all set to make this, I’m just wondering if using the whole container of Cool Whip will make it too loose. Please advise. Thanks!
Sarah says
I don’t find that it does!
Ella says
So, so good!! I use homemade whipped cream in place of the Cool-Whip and I did add 1/2 a teaspoon of coconut extract for an added flavor boost. I used coconut milk for the milk in this recipe as well.
I will say this makes a LOT of filling and I love that! But for those who find it is too much for your pie plate, just place the extra in a dish, refrigerate and enjoy it as coconut pudding. Just as yummy!!
Gabby says
Thanks for the tip that this will over fill a premade graham cracker crust from the store! I just cut the recipe in half and it was enough to fit perfectly in a store bought short bread crust. I only had to open another container of cool whip just to put on top.It was delicious! My husband loves coconut cream pie, it’s his favorite and this was a quick and easy recipe to follow.
Anon says
I have one question, can you freeze this?
Sarah says
Yes you can! Thaw in refrigerator though, not at room temperature! Allow at least a day to thaw in fridge.
Trish says
What an AWESOME Pie ! I have made several pies. We Love it!❤️
Heather says
Is there any substitute for sweetened condensed milk? I happened to leave that off my list🙄
The recipe is great btw! This is my second time making it. Thanks!
Katrina says
This was my first time making this kind of pie, my grand-daughter wanted one so this was the easiest one.
It was very delicious & easy to make, I actually had enough filling for 2 pies. My grand-daughter loved it.
Eileen says
This pie is fantastic! It’s very hard to find the pudding mix though! We were on a hunt and I finally found a store selling it. I might have grabbed 14 boxes, they are good till 2024! Coconut cream pie for every occasion now!!
Alice says
I’m making this tomorrow. Do you think by making fresh whipped cream it would alter the look/taste at all? TIA
Sarah says
No! That would be amazing!
Jo says
I love this recipe,but I can’t have milk
Could I use almond milk instead?
Sarah says
That should work okay!
Susan says
I used coconut milk and it was fantastic. Whipped coconut cream for the topping too. Yum.
Genie says
Made this for a gathering and everyone raved about it. There was nothing left to bring back home. Tasted great. I made it using graham cracker crust. It didn’t take long for the pie to set up. Will definitely make this again.
Susan says
Couldn’t find instant coconut pudding so I used vanilla mix and substituted the regular milk for coconut milk. I love coconut so I also whipped some coconut cream with my whipped cream for the topping. What a delicious mile high pie!!
Keri says
I’m excited to try this, but wanted to note that with a store-bought 9-inch graham cracker pie crust, the ingredients will DEFINITELY overflow. For anyone trying this recipe, 2 of these pie crusts WILL be needed or the ingredient measurements will need to be cut at least by a third, and I only emphasize that so others don’t make my mistake and get pie filling everywhere.
Dianne says
This is actually the best coconut pie ever! Very easy to make, following directions exactly as they are written, and could not believe how absolutely easy this was! I made my own crust as I personally do not buy the prepared ones. The taste is wonderful! Thank you so much!
Nonnie says
Can I use Banana cream pudding in stead .Nonnie
Sarah says
Sure! Any flavor, but then it will obviously incorporate that flavor…. enjoy!
Dianne says
A fabulous, quick pie! It is perfect as written, and we loved it! Very fluffy and light and delicious! I made a pie crust from scratch and baked it, then added filling and whipped cream! Toasted coconut on top! A great dessert and one of our faves! I have added variations for different pies, chocolate pudding for chocolate, banana pudding and sliced bananas for banana! All wonderful!
Sue says
This pie was so easy. A delicious, yummy summer dessert. Easy to collect ingredients, easy to beat together. Great dessert to have in our triple digit temperature
MARY SHARP says
WONDERFUL RECIPE. I ONCE HAD A RECIPE WHERE THE CRUST CONTINED COCONUT IN THE CRUST.THE FILLING HAD EAGLE BRAND MILK AND WHIPPING CREAM. THE TOP LATER HAD NUTTY TYPE GLAZE WITH COCNUT. LOST THE RECIPE SOMEHOW. I REMEMBER THIS RECIPE ONE SOME TYPE OF NATIONAL DAIRY CONTEST. I FOUND YOUR RECIPE AND I LOOK FORWARD TO TRYING IT.
Leeann mahurin says
This is my favorite pie ever!!! I couldn’t find coconut cream pudding so I used vanilla. But I used coconut milk , which gives it a fantastic coconut taste.
Sarah says
I love that substitution! Great idea as a stand-in for coconut pudding. Thanks for sharing!
Susan says
This pie is delicious! I always use unsweetened coconut though as it is plenty sweet as it is.
Sarah says
True! It is definitely plenty sweet. Unsweetened certainly works here!
Vicki says
Looking forward to making this creamy pie. Sounds quick and delicious!
Sarah says
Yay!
Cathy says
Hi,
I made this coconut cream pie exactly to your directions and I had too much pudding mixture for the 9 inch pie crust. Why did this happen? Do you fold in the whole 10 oz cool whip?
Carol Seaholts says
This is the tastiest coconut pie ever! I especially like it because it’s not too sweet. You’d think it would be..but the great flavor of the coconut shines through which gives it that “Island getaway “ feeling. Thanks so much for sharing a wonderful pie
Sarah says
So happy you liked it. Thank you so much for sharing your feedback! Happy Thanksgiving!
Christina says
Okay this might be a silly question but am I putting the whole container of whipped topping into the pie and none on top? Or do I save some to put on top?
Sarah says
That’s not a silly question, I probably could make it more clear. I use a little bit from another container for the topping. Use the whole carton in the pie!
Marge Bowman says
I don’t know what happened but mine didn’t turn out. It didn’t set up at all. I followed the directions to a T but it was super runny. It tastes good but too soupy. I may try again someday, I don’t know what happened.
Marge Bowman says
After reading all the comments I’m going to try this again. I was so looking forward to coconut cream pie today and don’t know what I did wrong but it sounds like it’s worth trying again.
Sarah says
I’m sorry you didn’t have a good experience. It’s quite easy overall. I would be glad to troubleshoot with you! Let me know what questions you may have before you make it next time!
Patti says
I made this and I had a friend say he will no longer buy store bought coconut cream pie again!! Now I make a pie for him every couple of months! It is delicious and so easy to make! Thank you for a great recipe ❤️
Sally Seibert says
Best pie ever! My favorite pie is coconut cream. The recipe has always been daunting to me. I saw this recipe with five stars, and gave it a try. Best coconut cream pie ever, and so easy.
Sarah says
So happy to hear this!! I’m thrilled you found something approachable and easy!!
Jen says
This pie is amazing and simple to put together! I have a friend that tells me everytime I make it
You could sale these!!
Alicia says
Wow! So Yummy! I cold not find Coconut pudding mix so I used cheesecake flavor instead and OMG. Def will be making this again!